In a significant legal move, the global delivery corporation initiated legal proceedings against the United States government this Monday, aiming to reclaim duties paid imposed under Donald Trump's administration, which the Supreme Court recently ruled were illegal.
A First Move in a Potential Wave of Lawsuits
This lawsuit represents the inaugural effort by a major corporation to get reimbursed for its portion of an approximate $175 billion in tariffs collected. The Supreme Court determined that the former president had exceeded his executive authority in issuing the tariffs, leading to expectations that other businesses will likely follow suit.
The lawsuit names as defendants US Customs and Border Protection (CBP), the agency’s commissioner Rodney Scott, and the United States of America. Submitted to the US Court of International Trade, the shipping firm did not specify an exact amount but stated it is pursuing a “full refund” for all duties paid.
“Although the supreme court did not address the question of reimbursements, we have taken required steps to safeguard the firm's legal rights as an importer of record to seek duty refunds from US Customs and Border Protection,” a written statement said.
Court Ruling and Administration's Response
Tariffs had become key component of the former administration's trade strategy during his second term, applied to goods from most nations worldwide using a novel interpretation of national emergency statutes as legal grounds.
In a 6-3 ruling last Friday, the court clarified that the legislative branch holds the exclusive power to impose taxes under the U.S. Constitution. It ruled that the IEEPA law cited by the administration could not legally be used to override that authority during peacetime.
The ruling marked the first time the Court has struck down Trump’s policies, undercutting his assertions of expansive presidential power. Yet, the court left unresolved whether businesses would be eligible for reimbursement.
In a dissenting opinion, Justice Brett Kavanaugh addressed the reimbursement question, claiming: “This decision is silent today about whether, and if so how, the government should go about returning the vast sums that it has collected from importers.” He added that “refunds of such large amounts would have significant consequences for the federal budget.”
Administration's Stance
The president quickly and harshly criticized the Court after the ruling, claiming it would not hinder his plans. He stated an intention to move forward with new global tariffs based on different statutes, quickly announcing a 10% global tariff which he later raised to 15% within a day.
“The policy remains unchanged. The statutory mechanisms that implement that could differ but the policy stays the same,” senior trade official Greer argued, saying it provides US business “significant negotiating power” in world trade.
Political Pressure for Reimbursement
At the same time, a group of Senate Democrats are advocating for refunds from the unlawfully gathered tariffs to be directed toward smaller enterprises. They have also pushed larger companies to redirect any funds received on to their customers.
According to an estimate from the Tax Foundation, the tariffs amounted to a $1,000 tax increase on average US households in a recent year.
“Past data and contemporary research demonstrate that import duties are forms of taxation that increase costs and reduce available quantities of goods and services for American companies and households,” their analysis stated, “leading to reduced earnings, fewer jobs, and lower economic output.”